How to Choose Accounting Software for a Small Business
Last updated
Every small business eventually outgrows the spreadsheet. The question is not whether you need accounting software, but which kind: a focused invoicing tool that keeps cash flowing, or a full bookkeeping suite your accountant can live in. The two overlap more every year, which is why the choice feels harder than it should.
This guide walks through the trade-offs that actually matter — how you get paid, whose currency you bill in, how many people need access, and how painful it is to leave. The deal pages list the current offers for each product; use this guide to figure out which one deserves your trial.
Start with how you get paid
If most of your revenue arrives as invoices you send to clients, start there. Invoicing-first tools like FreshBooks and Wave are built around the estimate-to-invoice-to-payment loop: send the invoice, track the time and expenses behind it, and accept the payment online. For freelancers and service businesses, that loop is most of the accounting job.
If you carry inventory, run payroll in-house, or need job costing and multi-entity books, you will outgrow an invoicing tool. Full suites like QuickBooks Online and Xero handle bank reconciliation, tax-ready reports, and the general ledger properly. The honest test: list the five accounting tasks you do every month. If most of them are invoicing-related, start invoicing-first; if they involve reconciliation, payroll, and reporting, start with a suite.
Mind the currency
Canadian businesses should check the currency story before anything else. FreshBooks is headquartered in Toronto and prices in Canadian dollars; Wave is a Canadian company where CAD handling feels native; QuickBooks Online ships a Canadian edition priced in CAD. Xero, by contrast, lists in USD — fine if your revenue is USD-heavy, but a needless exchange-rate surprise if it is not.
Currency is not just the sticker price. Ask how each product handles CAD bank feeds, GST and HST tracking, and the year-end reports your accountant expects. A tool that bills in CAD but fumbles Canadian tax categories has solved the easy half of the problem.
Count seats, not just features
Per-seat pricing quietly multiplies the cost of tools the whole team touches. Xero includes unlimited users on every tier — you pay for features, not seats — which makes it unusually economical for businesses where the bookkeeper, the owner, and the accountant all need in. Compare that against per-user pricing and do the math for your actual headcount, not the trial's.
Also check what a user means. Some products charge for anyone who logs in; others let your accountant in free or include view-only roles. If your accountant needs access — and they will at year end — find out what that costs before you commit.
Check the exit before you enter
Accounting data is the hardest data to move. Before you sign up, confirm you can export your full transaction history, customer list, and invoices in a standard format. Every product listed here lets you leave; the question is how much of your history comes with you and how many hours the cleanup takes.
Data migration is also the moment to switch. Moving from spreadsheets to your first real tool, or from one suite to another, is when a few hours of setup saves years of friction. Ask each vendor what migration help is included — some offer it free during onboarding, others treat it as a paid service.
Quick checklist
- List your five monthly accounting tasks — invoicing-heavy points to FreshBooks or Wave, reconciliation-heavy to QuickBooks or Xero.
- Confirm CAD billing and Canadian tax handling if you operate in Canada.
- Count everyone who needs a login, including your accountant, and price the seats.
- Check bank-feed support for your actual bank, not just most banks.
- Verify you can export everything — transactions, customers, invoices — before you import anything.
- Ask what migration help is included in onboarding versus billed extra.
Accounting products on PlanPrice
Every Accounting product we track — see verified pricing and current promotions on each deal page: